HACKS VITAE

STORIES, FILM & CULTURE · 7 POINTS LOOKED INTO

Comeback Stories, Part 2
Sanders, Jordan, Disney, Beethoven and Jobs

The stories of Colonel Sanders's 1,009 rejections, Michael Jordan being cut, Walt Disney fired for lacking imagination, Fred Astaire's screen test, Beethoven's Ninth, Steve Jobs and James Dyson: seven more famous comebacks, checked against the record.

HOVER A GLOWING POINT · DRAG TO TURN
  • Partly true 4
  • True 3
Published
September 16, 2026
Updated
September 29, 2026
Read
3 min
points
7

BACKGROUND · EL GRECO, VIEW OF TOLEDO, C. 1599–1600 · THE MET, OPEN ACCESS

THE SHORT VERSION

  1. Seven more famous comebacks, checked. Three hold up. Four are real stories carrying a detail that was added or changed.
  2. Michael Jordan did not make his school's varsity as a sophomore, but he was not dropped from basketball. He was put on the junior varsity, where the coach sent nearly all sophomores.
  3. Colonel Sanders's first franchise opened in 1952, four years before he sold his café at auction. We found no source for the 1,009 rejections.
  4. Disney's Kansas City studio, Laugh-O-Gram, was forced into bankruptcy by a creditor's petition filed on 4 October 1923. It was not his first company.
  5. The pattern from part one shows up again: Jobs came back to Apple carrying the software he had built while he was away.

What we found

Our reading of the evidence on each of the 7 points, with where it comes from. Open any row, look at the source, and make up your own mind.

Partly trueMichael Jordan was cut from his high school team

He did not make the varsity as a sophomore; he was not dropped from basketball. In 1978 Laney High School's varsity coach, Clifton "Pop" Herring, had one opening for a sophomore and gave it to the 6ft 7in Leroy Smith, because the team needed height. Jordan, "a skinny 5 feet, 9 inches" in one 1998 account, went to the junior varsity, became its centerpiece, and spent his last two years on the varsity. He took it personally and has said so: in 1991 he called it "embarrassing, not making that team".

SOURCE Kevin Sherrington, The Dallas Morning News, in The Seattle Times, 11 January 1998.

Partly trueColonel Sanders was rejected 1,009 times before anyone bought his recipe

The rejections and the late start are real; we found no source for the number. In the Rosenberg Center's account he was rejected again and again, and signed up only five restaurants in the first two years. His first franchised restaurant, run by Pete Harman, opened in South Salt Lake, Utah, in 1952. The rerouting of US 25 away from Corbin then drained his café's trade, and in 1956 he sold it at auction, at a loss, for $75,000. He went on the road selling franchises, and in 1964, with more than 600 franchises, sold the company for $2 million. The 1,009 figure is widely repeated; none of the histories we opened mention it.

SOURCE Smithsonian Magazine; Rosenberg International Franchise Center, University of New Hampshire.

Partly trueWalt Disney was fired from a newspaper for lacking imagination

We could not find the quotation; the setbacks are real. The "lacked imagination" line and a newspaper firing are not in the accounts we opened from D23, the Walt Disney Family Museum or the National Archives. What is documented: Disney and Ub Iwerks were laid off from the Pesmen-Rubin commercial art studio in Kansas City after the holiday rush, and started their own firm, Iwerks-Disney Commercial Artists, which lasted about a month. His later studio, Laugh-O-Gram Films, formed in May 1922, was forced into bankruptcy by a creditor's petition that Iwerks filed on 4 October 1923; the first meeting of creditors was set for 30 October 1923. Disney had already left Kansas City for California in late July 1923, for a new start.

SOURCE D23; the Walt Disney Family Museum; American Bankruptcy Institute; National Archives at Kansas City.

Partly trueFred Astaire's screen test said "Can't act. Can't sing. Balding. Can dance a little."

A dismissive note probably existed; the famous wording grew. Quote Investigator found good support for a studio evaluation written during an early screen test in the 1930s. The earliest printed version it found, from 1937, reads Slightly bald and can dance a little; a 1939 Fortune article gives Can't act; slightly bald; can dance a little. "Can't sing" came later: it is found by 1973.

SOURCE Quote Investigator.

TrueBeethoven wrote his Ninth Symphony while deaf

True; how much he could still hear is argued. In June 1801 he wrote that his hearing had been "getting weaker and weaker for 3 years", and from 1818 he used conversation books, in which people wrote their side. The Ninth premiered at the Kärntnertor Theatre in Vienna on 7 May 1824; the contralto soloist later told George Grove that she turned him round to face the applause. The usual view is that he was profoundly deaf by then. The musicologist Theodore Albrecht has argued that he still had some hearing in his left ear until shortly before his death.

SOURCE Beethoven-Haus Bonn; Grove (1898); Thomas et al. (2021); Theodore Albrecht, as reported by uDiscover Music.

TrueSteve Jobs was forced out of Apple, then came back

True, and the way he came back matters. He resigned from Apple in 1985, ousted as chairman, and founded NeXT; in 1986 he bought the computer division that became Pixar. Apple then acquired NeXT to make its operating system, NeXTSTEP, the basis for what became Mac OS X, released in March 2001. Jobs was firmly in charge again by August 1997. He returned with the product Apple needed.

SOURCE Computer History Museum; Pixar.

TrueJames Dyson built 5,127 prototypes before his vacuum worked

True by his own count, and the count is his own. In a 2011 column he described the 5,127 prototypes it took before the first model, the DC01, went on sale in 1993, some 15 years after he started (14, in another account). Licensing deals largely failed along the way, and in the end he made the machine himself.

SOURCE Dyson's 2011 column, as reported by Gizmodo; London Business School.

THE ARTICLE · 3 MIN

Part one checked six comebacks. In the three that held up, the turn came from a skill the person already had, not from keeping going alone. This part looks at seven more.

Three hold up. Four are real stories carrying a detail that was added or changed along the way.

What got added to the partly true stories

Look at what changed in the four that are partly true:

  • Jordan is “cut” from basketball, when the cut was from the varsity and he spent that season on the junior varsity.
  • Sanders gets an exact number: 1,009 rejections.
  • Disney gets an exact insult (“lacked imagination”), and a newspaper in place of the art studio that actually laid him off.
  • Astaire gets a longer, funnier screen-test note.

The additions rarely change the outline of what happened. Mostly they make it quotable. Our reading is that a number and a put-down are the two things a motivational post needs, and the record rarely supplies either.

The Jordan story is the most instructive

It has been told for decades, including in an NBA Entertainment film, and the part that changed is the part that makes it a story.

Laney High School in Wilmington, North Carolina, started with the 10th grade. In 1978 Jordan arrived for his sophomore year at “a skinny 5 feet, 9 inches”, according to a 1998 newspaper account by Kevin Sherrington of The Dallas Morning News. The varsity coach, Clifton “Pop” Herring, almost never carried sophomores, and that year he had one opening for a sophomore. His team lacked height, so the place went to Leroy Smith, who was 6ft 7in.

Jordan felt it. “It was embarrassing, not making that team,” he said in 1991. “They posted the roster and it was there for a long, long time without my name on it.” He became the centerpiece of the junior varsity, scoring more than 40 points in a couple of games, grew from 5ft 9in to 6ft 3in before his junior season, and spent his last two years on the varsity.

For a sophomore at that school, missing the varsity was the normal outcome, not a talent being written off. The anger was real, and he used it. That is still a useful story.

The pattern from part one, again

Jobs is the clearest case of what part one found. He founded NeXT in 1985 after he resigned from Apple, “ousted as chairman by a boardroom coup”, in the Computer History Museum’s words. By 1996 Apple needed a modern operating system and had failed to produce one of its own, so it bought NeXT “in order to make NeXTSTEP the basis for what eventually became Mac OS X”. Jobs came back with it, and was firmly in charge by August 1997. He returned carrying the software Apple needed.

Beethoven fits in a different way. His hearing had been failing since his late twenties, and from 1818 friends wrote their side of conversations in books. He went on composing through all of it, including the Ninth Symphony. Our reading is that what carried him was decades of training that the hearing loss could not take away.

This is our reading of the cases, not a law: keeping going kept them in the game, and something they had already built won it.

Sources

Checked September 2026.

Related: Comeback Stories, Part 1 · Overcoming survivorship bias · Conquer your fears: lessons from Cus D’Amato and Mike Tyson

  • comeback stories
  • resilience
  • fact check
  • cheat sheet
  • history
  • business

SHARE & CITE

Hacks Vitae. "Comeback Stories, Part 2: Sanders, Jordan, Disney, Beethoven and Jobs." September 16, 2026. https://www.hacksvitae.com/life-hack/comeback-stories-part-2-sanders-jordan-disney-beethoven-jobs

That's what we found. The rest is your call.

118 articles, each with its sources listed. Spotted something off? hacksvitae@gmail.com

Open the library